Something Rotten – Eggsistential Crisis

The New Yolkers

Friday, 11/10 @ 8
Sunday, 11/12 @ 12
Tuesday, 11/14 @ 8
Thursday, 11/16 @ 8
Saturday, 11/18 @ 8

Eggsistential Crisis

Saturday, 11/11 @ 8
Monday, 11/13 @ 8
Wednesday, 11/15 @ 8
Friday, 11/17 @ 8
Sunday, 11/19 @ 3


John Cullum Theatre at the American Theatre of Actors
314 W 54th St
New York, NY 10019

**Masks are optional but strongly encouraged. Some masks will be available at the theatre for a $1 donation per mask**

Ticket Prices and Details

Tickets for Something Rotten are now $37 per person, plus a $1.99 service fee.

After your purchase you will receive a receipt via email. No physical or electronic tickets will be sent. You will be able to check in at the door with the name of the ticket purchaser!


Seating in this theater is recessed stadium seating, and as such access to most of the seats in the theater requires traversing at least one step to sit down. (Pictures are included to show the step down into the seating area.) Wheelchair accessible seating in this theater is extremely limited and tickets purchased on this page are not wheelchair accessible. If you or anyone in your party needs to remain in a wheelchair throughout the performance, please click here to purchase a wheelchair accessible seat.

There are also three steps required to enter the building. We do have access to a small ramp that we can put out for anyone entering with a wheeled device. (A picture is included below to show the entrance steps.) If you don’t need a wheelchair accessible seat but you do need to use the ramp to enter the building, please purchase a ticket on this page for Eggsistential Crisis (or click here for The New Yolkers) and you will have the option to let us know that you need to use the ramp during check out.

If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us at

Cast Members

There are two casts of Something Rotten! Tickets on this page are for Eggsistential Crisis. Check the names below to make sure you are buying tickets for the right show!

Looking for The New Yolkers? Click here!

The New Yolkers

Adelaide Jenkins (she/her)
Alejandro Gallego
Amanda Harrigan (she/her) also 11/17
Cam Lieberson (they/them)
Carolyn Townsend (she/her)
Charlotte Robbins (she/her)
Chinaza Arungwa
David Teano
Eli Fisher (they/them) no 11/16
Ellen Pierson
Emma Nanamaker (she/her)
Harsha Dandibhotla
Ioanna Catsimalis (she/her)
Jayne Cayabyab (she/her) no 11/12
Jasmine Daniel (she/her)
Jen Lurie (she/her)
Jennifer Brodsky
Joseph Slevin (he/him)
Juan Vicente
Kathleen Perrier also 11/11
Karen Li (she/they)
Kayla Lee
Kimmianne Webster also 11/19
Kimmie Connolly (she/her)
Luke Stirpe (he/him)
Mayte Gamory (she/her)
Meghan Dressler (she/her)
Michael Bashner (they/he)
Michael J. Friedman (he/him)
Michelle Vidal (she/her)
Olivia Kokmen (she/her) no 11/16
Paul McNicholas
Sari Miller
Sol Kim
Stacia Woodcock (she/her)
Stephanie Campa (she/her)
Sydney Yaeger (she/her/hers) no 11/12
Tom Yeager (he/him)
Valerie Mark (she/her)
YJ Chen

Eggsistential Crisis

Adam Hardy (he/him)
Abby Schaeffer (she/her)
Alyssa Lukpat (she/her)
Carolina Ortiz (she/her/hers) also 11/12
Carrie Levine Allman (she/her)
Christina Colon (she/her/hers)
Ciara Loren Scott
Courtney Keyes (she/her)
Emily Hein (she/her)
Gina Milano
Harrison (he/him)
Hayley Marks (she/her)
Helen Yu (she/her) no 11/17
Jennie Mayfield (she/her) no 11/11
Jessica Fallon Gordon (she/her)
Jordan Silverman
Julia Reed (she/her)
Keidaï Lee (he/him)
Kevin Chan (he/they)
Khelsi Clarke
Kim Lo Leung (he/him)
Klara Moeckel (she/her) also 11/16
Kristin Furfaro
Laura Olson (she/her)
Lizz Saffrin (she/her)
Lochlyn Clark (she/her)
Madison Stevens (she/her) also 11/16
Megan Combs (she/her)
Misako Yamagishi (she/her)
Nayomi Shah no 11/19
Nesta Brenchley
Renée Veronica Badami
Rutu Samai (she/her)
Sabrina Kaplan (she/her) also 11/12
Stacy Oseas (she/her)
Stephanie Garace (she/her)
Tiffany Rhodes (she/her)
Timothy Oon (he/him)
Tori Babcock (she/her)
Tristan Overstreet
Vinnie Musolino (he/him)

COVID Safety

Masks are optional but strongly encouraged, especially in the first two rows of the theatre. Some masks will be available upon check in for a $1 donation (cash) per mask.

Refund/Exchange Policy

Tickets to an AfterWork Theater production are not refundable. Ticket purchasers may request to exchange tickets for another available performance date of the same production up until 48 hours prior to when their originally purchased performance begins, as long as it is also more than 48 hours before the requested performance. Please allow us at least 24 hours to try and accommodate your change request. We may not be able to accommodate exchange requests as it comes close to each performance time. To request a ticket exchange, please reach out to us via email at

If a performance is cancelled due to extenuating circumstances outside the control of AfterWork Theater, there will be no refunds issued or exchanges made, and the value of your unused ticket will be considered a donation to AWT for which you will receive a receipt for tax purposes.


The numbers below include tickets for this event already in your cart. Clicking "Get Tickets" will allow you to edit any existing attendee information as well as change ticket quantities.
Tickets are no longer available